Doctor Who
Warning : spoilers forward for Doctor Who time of year 14 , episode 6 , " Rogue . "
Summary
Doctor Wholives up to its title as season 14 sneakily introduces a mystery story fount into the Doctor ’s regeneration line , but this entrant may really be a ghost from the franchise ’s past . Doctor Whoperiodically like to remind audiences of old regenerations , whether via the scribbled drawings of John Smith in " Human Nature , " or when the Atraxi examined its records on Earth before promptly running away in " The Eleventh Hour . " The image resurface inDoctor Whoseason 14 , episode 6 , " Rogue , " as Rogue ’s ship scans the Doctor and adjure up a series of holograms describe past regenerations .
Rogue ’s scanner showsevery actor who has played the Doctor inDoctor Who , ranging from William Hartnell ’s First Doctor to Ncuti Gatwa ’s Fifteenth , as well as John Hurt ’s War Doctor and Jo Martin ’s Fugitive Doctor . In a deliberate curveball plan to ignite argumentation , however , the " Rogue " holograph sequence also include an extra Doctor not immediately recognizable as any prior positive feedback . Despite being a relatively fresh addition toDoctor Who ’s official canyon , this Doctor may actually predate the entire modern epoch .
doc Who has been a fixture on TV screens for 60 years , meaning there are plenty of stories to take from when picking out the Time Lord ’s best .
Doctor Who’s New Canon Doctor Is Richard E. Grant’s Shalka Doctor
2003’s Forgotten Doctor Gets A Canon Promotion
The surprise Doctor nuzzle between William Hartnell and Tom Baker bears an undeniably unattackable resemblance to Richard E. Grant . TheWithnail & IandSaltburnstar previously portrayed Walter Simeon before becoming the fount of the Great Intelligence in Matt Smith ’s epoch , but also bring the Doctor themselves to spirit on two separate occasions . In 1999 , Grant bring together a procession of notable British thespian parodying the Doctor in comedy cartoon " The Curse of Fatal Death . " Four old age later , Grant voice his own likeness as the Doctor in BBC ’s animated " Scream of the Shalka . "
medico Who has featured hatful of regenerations over the years , with the best embodying some of the show ’s most important melodic theme and elements .
Since the aspect transmit , original " Scream of the Shalka " author , Paul Cornell , has tacitly confirmed thehologram in " Rogue " is intended to be Richard E. Grant ’s Shalka Doctorvia his Instagram . This removes any smidgin of doubt , as , despite await very strongly like Richard E. Grant , the font could have potentially been an older Valeyard , or a random aspect intend to throw a wrench into canon without any rime or reason .
While the holograph does limn Richard E. Grant ’s Shalka Doctor , some alterations have clearly been made . The gothic paleness and razor - sharp sideburns from the animated version have been modulate down , and Grant ’s Doctor reckon visibly older - near to the role player ’s age in 2024 than when he portrayed the Shalka Doctor in 2003 . disregarding , it does appear that season 14 has formally inducted the Shalka Doctor into the show ’s prescribed line ofDoctor Whoregenerations .
Doctor Who’s “Scream Of The Shalka” Explained
A Forgotten Doctor Who Oddity That Was Rapidly Usurped
compose by Paul Cornell , who would later go on to compose episodes ofDoctor Who ’s innovative serial , " Scream of the Shalka " was an prescribed BBC production released in 2003 as an online scoop - still something of a novelty at the clock time . Despite being animated , " Scream of the Shalka " was vaunt as a continuation of the original series and 1996 pic followingDoctor Who ’s cancellation in 1989 . Richard E. Grant ’s Ninth Doctor occupied the dismal end of the champion ’s personality spectrum and took Sophie Okonedo ’s Alison as his fellow traveler , but also traveled with a robotic version of the Master played by Derek Jacobi , who would ultimately recapitulate the role on boob tube .
Richard E. Grant would not recapitulate his role on television , however . Russell T. Davies ' plot of land to bringDoctor Whoback to mainstream prominence immediately outshone " Scream of the Shalka . " There would be no continuation of the online story , andDoctor Who ’s 2005 relaunch in effect scrubbed the chapter from canon entirely .
Where Doctor Who’s Shalka Doctor Fits Into The Doctor’s Timeline
Something That Was Already Wibbly-Wobbly Just Got Timey-Wimey
Officially utter , theShalka Doctor is an unofficial translation of the Ninth Doctor . " Scream of the Shalka " debut long after thefailedDoctor WhoTV moviewith Paul McGann as the Eighth Doctor , but shortly before Russell T Humphrey Davy bring the franchise back to prominence and cast Christopher Eccleston as the real Ninth Doctor for TV . RTD famously criticized Richard E. Grant ’s take on the Doctor and reassert the worker was never considered for work the role inDoctor Who ’s modern earned run average ( viaBBC ) .
It ’s executable that when Paul McGann ’s atomic number 83 - generate Eighth Doctor next died after " The Night of the Doctor , " he regenerate into Richard E. Grant instead of Christopher Eccleston .
This period of the Doctor ’s timeline was complicate further by Steven Moffat , who squeezed a totally dissimilar MD - the War Doctor - between Eight and Nine . Paul McGann regenerated into John Hurt during " The Night of the Dr. , " then Hurt regenerated into Christopher Eccleston in the final here and now of " The Day of the Dr. , " filling in any missing spread fromDoctor Who ’s void class between 1990 and 2005 . Because of this , the Shalka Doctor does not fit easily intoDoctor Whocanon , but there are other agency of excuse how Richard E. Grant may now be considered a canyon Doctor actor after " Rogue . "
The latest Doctor Who series introduces the Fifteenth Doctor, joined by new companion Ruby Sunday.
first of all , Doctor Whocould retcon the Shalka Doctor into a pre - Hartnell Doctor , like Jo Martin . The arrival of the Fugitive Doctor andDoctor Who ’s subsequent Timeless Child twistconfirmed the universe of an unspecified number of doctor prior to the First . These regeneration called themselves " the MD " and playact like the Doctor , but were forgotten due to a Time Lord memory rub . Richard E. Grant may now count himself among them .
Ncuti Gatwa stimulate a standout consequence in Doctor Who season 14 ’s " Dot & Bubble " episode , but it also highlights what the current run is missing .
On the other hand , Richard E. Grant ’s Shalka Doctor could be a parallel universe of discourse Ninth Doctor . In sixtieth anniversary special " The Giggle , " the Toymaker claimed to have made a " fretsaw " out of the Doctor ’s history - a pipeline RTD himself described as looseningDoctor Who ’s canon rules in the episode ’s comment . The universe of a 2nd Ninth Doctor could be the Toymaker ’s break , like most other unknown occurrences in time of year 14 .
Another potential account can be found inDoctor Who ’s bi - contemporaries scene , also from " The Giggle . " harmonise to RTD during his commentary , the Fourteenth Doctor ’s bi - generation rippled through time , bringing all previous Doctors back to life history . The Eighth Doctor , therefore , would have awoken on Karn , right as rain , and gotten on with his life . What happens to these bi - sire doctor when they become flat is currently not get laid , so it ’s feasible that when Paul McGann ’s bi - generated Eighth Doctor next died after " The Night of the Doctor of the Church , " he regenerate into Richard E. Grant instead of Christopher Eccleston - an alternative Ninth Doctor .
The Doctor Isn’t Necessarily Aware Of Their New Regeneration
The New Doctor Opens Up An Intriguing Conversation: Does Fifteen Recognize Them?
One of the key questions fromDoctor Whoseason 14 ’s hologram scene is whether Ncuti Gatwa ’s Fifteenth Doctor actually knows about this mysterious young face . Since the Division wiped the Doctor ’s memory prior to Hartnell , Doctor Who ’s protagonist should only have sex about the positive feedback that audience are also familiar with : the main 15 plus Hurt and Martin . Strangely , however , Ncuti Gatwa ’s Doctor does n’t so much as enhance an eyebrow when an entirely new holographic look flashes before his center in Rogue ’s ship .
At first glance , the Fifteenth Doctor ’s lack of response might imply that he knows precisely who this secret re-formation is and remembers the point in clip when he looked like Richard E. Grant . On the other hand , the Fifteenth Doctor is somewhat occupied duringDoctor Whoseason 14 ’s hologram scene , turn in an all-powerful soliloquy and trying to convince a bountifulness hunter not to stamp out him . One might also impeach the Doctor of being double unhinge by his not - so - insidious attraction to Rogue . It ’s possible , therefore , that the Doctor just does n’t notice the impostor among the holograph , nor that the procession contains one more physician than there should be .
germ : BBC
sequence
Disney+ Release Date
" Space Babies " and " The Devil ’s Chord "
May 10
" Boom "
May 17
" 73 chiliad "
May 24
" Dot & Bubble "
May 31
" Rogue "
June 7
" The Legend of Ruby Sunday "
June 14
" Empire of Death "
June 21
The latest Doctor Who serial publication bring out the Fifteenth Doctor , unite by fresh fellow traveler Ruby Sunday .
